5 Expensive Mistakes People Make with Gift Cards

Gift cards are everywhere—birthdays, bonuses, promotions, apologies, refunds. They’re marketed as the perfect present: flexible, simple, and thoughtful. But in practice, most people make the same five mistakes with them. And those mistakes cost real money.

Whether it’s letting cards expire, spending them on junk, or just forgetting they exist, the result is the same: lost value.

Here’s how to avoid the most common gift card traps—and why it’s often smarter to sell gift card instead of holding onto them “just in case.”

Mistake #1: Letting Gift Cards Sit for Months (or Years)

Most people tuck gift cards away “for later.” But later becomes never. According to surveys, over 47% of adults have at least one unused gift card. And billions go unspent each year globally.

Why it hurts:

Gift cards can lose value over time. Some expire. Some charge inactivity fees. Others simply get lost or forgotten. That €50 card from last Christmas? It might be worth nothing by the time you rediscover it.

What to do instead:

Check the balance, and if you’re not using it this month, sell gift card while it still holds value. You can get 80–95% of the card’s amount back—often within minutes.

Mistake #2: Using Them on Stuff You Don’t Actually Need

Just because you have a card doesn’t mean you need what the store sells. Yet people feel pressure to use it—and end up buying low-quality items or unnecessary extras to burn the balance.

Why it hurts:

It leads to clutter, overspending, and buyer’s remorse. A €50 card turns into €90 spent, and you’re stuck with things you didn’t plan to purchase.

What to do instead:

Ask yourself: “Would I buy this with my own money?” If the answer is no, sell the card. Platforms like Noones let you list your card and choose how you want to get paid—cash, PayPal, mobile wallet, or crypto.

Mistake #3: Accepting a Bad Trade-In Rate

Some people try to cash in gift cards by selling them to local shops or big buyback sites—but only get 50–60% of the card’s value in return.

Why it hurts:

You’re losing half your money just to make the card usable. That’s not a trade—it’s a bad deal.

What to do instead:

Use a peer-to-peer platform where you control the terms. Noones connects you directly to buyers who actually want the card, meaning you can recover far more value. You set your price, approve the trade, and get paid fast.

Mistake #4: Holding Out for “Someday”

You keep thinking: “I’ll use this card eventually.” But life moves fast. Stores rebrand. Retailers close locations. Brands change policies. That card you’re saving could be worthless next quarter.

Why it hurts:

Postponing use is the easiest way to end up with nothing. Even digital cards can expire, and older platforms don’t always offer customer support for redemptions.

What to do instead:

If you haven’t used it in 3–6 months, sell it. Liquid value beats locked potential every time. Convert it into something you actually need—groceries, rent, savings, or stability.

Mistake #5: Not Realizing You Can Sell It at All

This is the big one. Most people don’t even realize it’s legal—and easy—to sell a gift card. They assume it’s stuck with them forever, or that it’ll be too hard to trade safely.

Why it hurts:

Untapped value sits idle. And sometimes, that value could solve a real problem—covering a bill, helping with a financial emergency, or just reducing stress.

What to do instead:

Use platforms built for exactly this. Noones is designed to make gift card selling safe, fast, and profitable. You don’t need tech skills or financial experience. You just need a card and a reason to unlock its value.

Smart Move: Turn Traps into Cash

Gift cards aren’t the problem—how we handle them is. If you’re making any of the five mistakes above, you’re not alone. But you don’t have to keep losing money.

Here’s what smart consumers are doing:

• Selling cards they won’t use
• Turning unused credit into actual spending power
• Using peer-to-peer tools like Noones instead of taking low trade-in rates
• Building a habit of converting locked value into flexible money

It’s a practical, everyday financial strategy that takes less than 10 minutes—and can make your money more useful immediately.

Final Thought

A gift card should never feel like a burden. But if it’s tying up your money, cluttering your wallet, or forcing purchases you don’t want, it’s time to make a better choice.

Don’t let brands win by your inaction. Don’t lose money to forgetfulness or guilt.

Sell gift card now, and start treating your value like it belongs to you—not the brand.

Visit the rest of the site for more interesting and useful articles.